Hello dear
Welcome to Joe Cristiano's Pizza
Joe Cristiano's Pizza, located in Hyde Park, NY, is a local gem celebrated for its exceptional pizza and friendly service. Patrons rave about the perfect cheese-to-sauce ratio and expertly crafted crust, with many highlighting the importance of achieving that ideal crispiness. The menu also includes a variety of scrumptious wings and delightful desserts, such as chocolate chip cookies, making it a favorite destination for game nights. With a dedicated staff and a commitment to quality, Joe Cristiano's Pizza stands out in the culinary scene, ensuring a memorable dining experience for every customer.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
Joe Cristiano's Pizza
Welcome to Joe Cristiano's Pizza, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Hyde Park, NY. Whether you're a pizza enthusiast or just someone looking for a hearty meal, this establishment stands out for its exceptional offerings and warm atmosphere. Situated at 1225 NY-9G, this pizzeria is a beloved local spot, known not just for its food, but also for its friendly staff who treat customers with genuine care.
At Joe Cristiano's Pizza, every visit feels special. The enthusiastic reviews from satisfied customers speak volumes about the quality of the food. One frequent diner, Conrad Moser, shares how he makes a weekly ritual out of picking up their specialty pizza and wings for game night, often indulging in their delectable chocolate chip cookies for a sweet finish. It’s this kind of dedication to flavor and a memorable dining experience that keeps patrons coming back.
What draws many to Joe Cristiano's is their dedication to crafting the perfect pizza. Customer James S. Cintron raves about the "best pizza around," praising the balance of cheese and sauce that make every bite a delight. The crust, described as "just right," adds to that signature touch, ensuring that every pizza is not just a meal, but a culinary experience.
In addition to their stellar pizzas, Joe Cristiano's wings come highly recommended. With an array of flavors to choose from, they cater to all kinds of palates. Many loyal customers, like John Kladis, have made it a habit to request their wings "extra crispy," underscoring the restaurant's dedication to customization and perfection.
The management, led by the great Lyle, is another highlight of Joe Cristiano's Pizza. Reviewers note the high level of culinary excellence and the commitment to customer satisfaction that flow from the kitchen. Although some have pointed out the heat in the dining area, it’s clear that the staff works hard to ensure a top-tier dining experience, leaving diners content with every bite.
To sum it up, Joe Cristiano's Pizza is not merely a place to grab a slice; it’s a community favorite where great food and even better service collide. Whether you're there for game night, a family dinner, or simply to enjoy a delicious meal, you'll leave with your cravings satisfied and a smile on your face. Make sure to stop by or call +1 845-229-8125 to experience what many have dubbed the finest pizza around.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ I pick up a specialty pizza and wings every week for game night. Sometimes so desserts too - the chocolate chip cookies are delicious! Food's great, the staff are great. ”
“ Food is great staff are always friendly.. they treat their employers and customers very well ”
“ Best pizza around. Cheese is just right, sauce is great and they put plenty of it on. Crust just right. ”
“ Really good food and pizza. I alternate between the Salt Point location and Hyde park. Funny thing is, I always ask for my pizza or wings to be crispy. EXTRA crispy. 9 times out of 10 the Hyde Park location gets it right! But nine times out of 10 Salt Point gets it wrong. Sometimes even an "overly soft" crust. Try some of their wings flavors! ”
“ Lyle is an exquisite and manager who can make a succulent pizza. Who ever makes meals most week nights is also a superb chef, everything is cooked perfect. My only complaint is that this location is incredibly hot. I can tell by the way the employees are sweating. Would appreciate seeing your staff treated better. ”
“ Overall - Low profile presence but great quality pie Food - Had a White Delight. Many places struggle with a good non-red sauce pizza, but they were on point. Good ingredients, cooked just right, and even larger than expected. Service - Greeted promptly, ordering was easy, delivered timely. Atmosphere - Mostly a takeout place, but there is room for a small group to sit and enjoy their meal. Price - Very reasonably priced. ”
“ It was 7:45 on a Sunday night and we'd been traveling all day, car issues, up at 3am for an airport run, the whole 9. Anyhow, we're getting to our airbnb and turned into Joe's before their 8pm closing time. They'd just washed all the floors and were closing up for they day. They offered the nice variety of pizza by the slice, which was our choice and excellent! But offered to make us anything on the menu, not rushing us out, gave us free garlic knots and then came and offered an order of chicken wings because they'd just dropped it in the cooker when the order was canceled! Great food, amazing service, they bent over backwards! Highly recommend these guys and their wonderful pizza! ”
“ Best Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza I have had in a long time. Very flavorful and the crust is a perfect crisp. Thank you. ”